Fantasy with Friends A Discussion Meme Hosted by Pages Unbound

Fantasy with Friends is a weekly meme hosted by the good people over at Pages Unbound. Fantasy with Friends poses questions each Monday about fantasy, either as a genre as a whole or individual works.

This week’s prompt is:

If you had the opportunity to ask any fantasy author about an aspect of their work or what they were thinking when writing, whom would you choose and what would you ask?

When I saw this prompt, I thought—well, this will be incredibly easy. I’ll just sit down and the questions will pour out. My problem would be cutting myself off/limiting myself to the one that the prompt asked for.

But when I sat down this weekend to do so…I drew a blank. I mean the prompt only asks for one, but the two I’ve managed to come up with seem trifling. You don’t want to throw away your shot like this, this kind of opportunity comes once in a lifetime, yo. Right?

For Jim Butcher: why tease us with a Jade Court of vampires, and never say anything about it. The other courts seem to be global, why is it geographically limited to the other side of the world? When are we going to see them and learn about them?

I do have a question for J.R.R. Tolkein based on this little bit from The Fellowship:

A fox passing through the wood on business of his own stopped several minutes and sniffed. “Hobbits!” he thought. “Well, what next? I have heard of strange doings in this land, but I have seldom heard of a hobbit sleeping out of doors under a tree. Three of them! There’s something might queer behind this.”

He was quite right, but he never found out more about this.

Say what? You just drop this kind of thing once and we don’t get anything like it for the rest of the trilogy? (and honestly,  I only have this one because I saw some meme about it this weekend)

I’m sure that were I to pick up individual titles, I’d come up with some other minor things—especially if I made notes about it. But most of those questions are either so minor (see the fox) that I forget about them almost instantly, or the book is good enough that I stop caring. In novels that don’t answer the questions, I won’t remember it, but I’ll remember a sense of dissatisfaction with the book, and will only remember why if I did make myself a note or I re-read.

Beyond that, the questions I want to ask authors have to do with the origin of the ideas—inspiration for a character, a monster, a type of magic—where did Novel X come from? What character or idea surprised you once you started putting it into action and you had to curtail it or emphasize it as you went along because you were having so much fun and/or it just wasn’t working?

Okay, that’s not true—there are several authors I want to ask about certain character deaths (I won’t list them here for spoiler reasons), that tear-stained list would start with Lloyd Alexander and Margaret Weis /Tracy Hickman, and keep going through Z.B. Steele.

At the end of the day, the story will either answer your questions or make you forget them long-term.

Now, I’m off to read the other posts linked to in the Pages Unbound post (as well as that post itself), so I can bask in the cleverness and curiosity of those contributors.

Irresponsible Reader Pilcrow Icon