Author: HCNewton Page 257 of 623

Ohh, right…Peter Jackson Knew What He Was Doing (thoughts inspired by The Fellowship of the Rings Audiobook)

Tom BombadilSo I’m listening to the audiobook for The Fellowship of the Rings right now, and I spent some time today on the Tom Bombadil section—sooo much time (my rough estimate is 96 minutes).

I remember the first time I went through the book wondering what the purpose of all that time in the book was, but assumed I didn’t just didn’t get something, or that there’d be a payoff by the end of The Return of the King. I was curious about how the movies would handle that portion, but eventually, I shrugged it off and forgot about it. I remembered it when I walked out of the movie, thinking, “Hey, they left that bit out!”* and “good move.”

* After The Hobbit trilogy, it is hard to think of Jackson leaving things out, but it was something he did once upon a time.

Now I know that I’m not alone in not appreciating the Bombadil bits, and I can understand some of the defenses. Understand, but don’t buy them. I just don’t see the point of almost everything that happens for that hour and a half. (Feel free to tell my why I’m wrong!!) That said, Serkis almost made this bit tolerable. Almost.

That said, there have been some good things to come out of that character, and I figured I’d take the opportunity to boost the signal on them, since I’ve been thinking about them while listening to this part of the book. For example:

bullet The song, “In The House of Tom Bombadil” by Nickel Creek, which I could (and have) listen to on repeat for the better part of an hour.

bullet A few strips from the Sheldon comic by Dave Kellett (he may have others, but these are what I can find):
bullet CONVENTIONS!!!
bullet Support Group for Lame Sci-Fi and Fantasy Characters
bullet What Else Did We Miss from “The Lord of the Rings”?
bullet More Tom! More Tom! (meeting Lewis and Tolkein while time-travelling)
bullet Tra-la-lee!

All these are available in Pop Culture!…Building a Better Tomorrow by Avoiding Today by Dave Kellett, one of my favorite comic collections from the last few years.
Pop Culture

I really don’t have a point or anything, just needed to do something in response to the Tom Bombadil experience.

Jumping Sharks and Dropping Mics by Gareth Carrol: Adding Some Flavor to Our Speech

Jumping Sharks and Dropping MicsJumping Sharks and Dropping Mics:
Modern Idioms and Where
They Come From

by Gareth Carrol

DETAILS:
Publisher: iff Books
Publication Date: February 25, 2022
Format: eARC
Length:176 pg.
Read Date: February 10-11, 2022
Support Independent Bookstores - Visit IndieBound.org

What’s Jumping Sharks and Dropping Mics About?

The subtitle pretty much tells you everything you need to know. This is a look at several idioms, expressions, and figures of speech that have entered common usage over since the latter half of the twentieth century.

The introductory chapter describes idioms and their usage, the various types of idioms, the history of a few not-modern examples, and so on. This chapter was great and I could’ve used a whole book on this topic. But that’s something for a future library trip, I guess.

Following that we get chapters devoted to: Idioms from TV (including from commercials); Movies; The Internet (memes, hashtags, and so on); Sports; Modern Literature; and then a handful that have entered common usage without a tie to any of the rest, some from the news. that sort of thing.

Carrol talks about the origin and spread of each idiom, notable uses outside the source, and clarifies the meaning—and other commentary or trivia.

Oh, It’s That Kind of English…

Early on there was something in the back of my mind, like I was missing something. Then I ran across the phrase “TV advert,” and a lightbulb went on over my head. This book comes from the other side of the Atlantic, which is going to affect a little bit what idioms are used.

I’m not complaining or anything, I just had to tweak my expectations and go in knowing that there were going to be a few things I had no previous exposure to or that I’d be going into without the necessary frame of reference.

So, what did I think about Jumping Sharks and Dropping Mics?

The Sports chapter did nothing for me—most of that is my utter disinterest in the category, but a decent chunk of that is due to the number of cricket references. They might as well have been in Greek.

On the other end of the spectrum, as one might expect, the chapter devoted to Modern Literature was my favorite. Not just because of the page or two devoted to Douglas Adams, either. The section on The Right Stuff was a lot of fun.

There weren’t a lot of idioms that were new to me, but there were a handful—I’ve tried them out a little bit in the few days since I read the book, I’m not sure they’re going to stick, but you never know. It’s fun to watch people try to suss out what I meant, at least.

The book was a lot of fun, I appreciated re-familiarizing myself with some of these phrases, and I learned a couple of things, too. It was an entertaining read and just the kind of thing that language nerds should really enjoy.

Disclaimer: I received this eARC from John Hunt Publishing Ltd, via NetGalley in exchange for this post—thanks to both for this.


3 Stars

This post contains an affiliate link. If you purchase from it, I will get a small commission at no additional cost to you. As always, opinions are my own.

The Blood Tide by Neil Lancaster: A Gripping Sequel, Stronger than its Predecessor

The Blood TideThe Blood Tide

by Neil Lancaster

DETAILS:
Series: DS Max Craigie Scottish Crime Thrillers, #2
Publisher: HQ
Publication Date: February 23, 2022
Format: eARC
Length: 384 pgs.
Read Date: February 7-9, 2022

Dead Man’s Grave Spoilers Ahead

It’s impossible to talk about this sequel to Dead Man’s Grave without spoiling it. If you haven’t read that yet, go read my post about it and skip this post. (but thanks for the blog view, I always appreciate the visit)

What’s The Blood Tide About?

It’s been a few months (if we’re told specifically, I missed it) since Dead Man’s Grave, but not too long. Tam Hardie’s in prison for his crimes, his wife and kids are out of the country, and his syndicate is in trouble from without and within. The Policing Standards Reassurance Team, now established, is still trying to find Hardie’s remaining contact(s) in the police. On the personal side, Max Craigie’s wife has moved back in with him, and things are going well.

Basically, things are in a good place. This means it’s time for things to happen—a fisherman goes missing on a routine fishing trip (well, a routine something anyway), not long after that, an intelligence officer with the National Crime Agency commits suicide—and the only witness’s notes go missing, too. And then there’s another (apparent) suicide. There’s almost no reason for anyone to see a link between them—but once Max Craigie is shown the link, he’s able to convince the rest of his team and soon will get more proof.

This is where things get really dicey—and the Team is immersed in a case involving drugs, murder, corrupt officials—and at least one criminal in their own midst.

Characters

In the previous book, we got a pretty good handle on DS Max Craigie and DC Janie Calder. In this book, we get to know their boss, DI Ross Fraser better as he’s able to take a greater leadership role (since it’s not an off-the-books investigation anymore) and as we see him deal with problems in his home life.

We also get introduced to a new member of their team, and get to know her fairly well. I liked the fact that we didn’t come into this book with a greatly expanded team, and only added someone after this book’s action had started—it helps the readers to connect with everyone, and it’s also a nice touch of realism, if the team expands too quickly, it’d be more difficult to keep it to those who can be trusted.

Policing the Police

Max and his team operate far differently from the other fictional Scottish detective looking into Police Corruption that I’m familiar with—Malcolm Fox. There’s no way that Fox in his role with Complaints and Conduct would pursue a case this way (although by the end of his time with them, that had started to change, and he might be more open to it).

The Policing Standards Reassurance Team is a band of mavericks, or at least operate as a collective maverick—going back to their inception. They seem more effective running that way—although I do wonder about realism (for those who care about such things—and it’s more exciting to read about than a bunch of people being careful about paperwork.

So often reading what Max and Janie are going through, I wondered how they trust anyone in the Police service. It almost seems like luck when they have an operation go well without someone having leaked something to their target. Does that take a toll on people? I wonder if Lancaster will deal with that in the future.

So, what did I think about The Blood Tide?

It is really hard to talk about this in any kind of detail—the twists and reveals start early on and I fear I may have said a bit too much already.

I will say as someone who’s been reading Lancaster from the beginning, that it’s great to see his growth as an author—the writing, the characterization, the details in The Blood Tide is leagues beyond what his debut displayed. And I enjoyed his debut, and would’ve kept reading him if he kept producing books like it. It’s just so much easier to do when they’re as good as this one.

Along the same lines, there’s growth to this series—as ought to be expected. Dead Man’s Grave was about establishing this world, these characters, and their mission. Now we get to see them in action, we’re ready to see them at work, in danger, and taking on bigger challenges.

Do I recommend The Blood Tide? You bet—a good author getting better at his craft, a handful of strong characters, and a plot that’ll keep you guessing as it ratchets up the tension. Grab both of the DS Max Craigie thrillers and you’ll be in for a good time. The third book is due this autumn, which is too far away for my tastes.


4 Stars

Disclaimer: I received this eARC from HQ via NetGalley in exchange for this post—thanks to both for this.

WWW Wednesday, February 16, 2022

Time for WWW Wednesday, that lovely part of the week where I pretend to be organized.

This meme was formerly hosted by MizB at A Daily Rhythm and revived on Taking on a World of Words—and shown to me by Aurore-Anne-Chehoke at Diary-of-a-black-city-girl.

The Three Ws are:

What are you currently reading?
What did you recently finish reading?
What do you think you’ll read next?

Easy enough, right?

What are you currently reading?

I’m reading Light Years From Home by Mike Chen and am listening to The Fellowship of the Ring by J.R.R. Tolkein, Andy Serkis (Narrator) on audiobook—it’s so long, I fully expect to see it in this spot next week, too.

Light Years From HomeBlank SpaceThe Fellowship of the Ring

What did you recently finish reading?

I just finished a pair of hard-boiled novels: The Goodbye Coast by Joe Ide and Dead Man in a Ditch by Luke Arnold on audio.

The Goodbye CoastBlank SpaceDead Man in a Ditch

What do you think you’ll read next?

My next book will be the next Stonebridge Mystery, All At Sea by Chris McDonald—so you know I’m eager to dive in. My next audiobook should be Quest by A.J. Ponder, Benjamin Fifes (Narrator), a book I literally remember nothing about, so that should lead to a surprise or two.

All At SeaBlank SpaceQuest

How about you?

Spelling the Month in Books: February

Spelling the Month in Books: February
I kept the focus this month on books I haven’t read in a decade or more. Sadly, despite having read most of the books listed here multiple times, my memory about them is pretty rusty. Still, it was fun thinking about them again, and I can fairly confidently recommend them all.

F Faces of the Dead

Faces of the Dead

Brad Parks made his fiction debut with this novel, the first in his series about investigative reporter Carter Ross (a series that has shown up in his stand-alone works, too). I don’t know how long it took me to get into this book/series, but I’d be willing to bet it was less than 50 pages. I just clicked with Ross right away—he had a nice style, and watching one of the last print reporters in fiction do his thing was a blast.

E The Extraordinary Adventures of Alfred Kropp

The Extraordinary Adventures of Alfred Kropp

Rick Yancey was a discovery my eldest and I made about the same time (it’s possible it was the same trip to the Library), I was reading his Highly Effective Detective series, and my son went with this (and I soon followed). This high schooler and his guardian uncle set out to steal Excalibur (yes, that one) and things get stranger from there. Arthurian bad guys, demons, and all sorts of lesser evil types running around. It’s got a more fun, almost Percy Jackson-feel (they were released the same year, so it might have been something in the air) than Yancey’s other YA stuff. I only have very vague memories of the series, but they’re fond memories.

B Big Trouble

Big Trouble

Dave Barry’s first novel is hilarious. He’s grown as a novelist and his more recent work is much better, but this was funny. Which is really all you want in a Dave Barry book—the plot involved an advertising executive, a couple of hitmen, an embezzler, and a couple of high schoolers. Some odd event kicks off a chain reaction bringing all of these together in a comic crime disaster that could only happen in Florida.

Barry Sonnenfeld made a movie adaptation from this starring Time Allen, Rene Russo, Stanley Tucci, among others. It wasn’t Sonnenfeld’s best, but it was okay, as I recall.

R Rizzo's War

Rizzo’s War

Lou Manfredo’s debut kicks off a gripping trilogy. Rizzo is an NYPD detective headed toward retirement, partnered with a rookie detective to show him the ropes. Unlike most police procedurals, the partners dealt with several cases at once—with (I think) one dominating their attention for most of the book—although it might have traded places with another case for the home stretch. I’m pretty sure I read this in 2009, so my memory is vague. Neither Rizzo nor his partner are super-cops, they’re just guys trying to get the job done in the best way they can and go home at the end of their shift. This one reeked of authenticity.

U Underground

Underground

This is the third in Kat Richardson’s Greywalker series (finally, something that isn’t a first on this list!), and it’s a doozy. As I recall, Harper Blaine is basically Kinsey Millhone with ghosts and other supernatural whatnot, a PI who after a near-death experience can see the dead. Something is awakening a Native American monster in Seattle that’s eating people (a whole bunch of homeless people, I think)—and it’s up to Harper to stop it.

I never got around to reading the rest of the series, and I’ve often wondered why. Just thinking about it a little now has made question a few decisions I made.

A The Accidental Sorcerer

The Accidental Sorcerer

K.E. Mills’s fantasy series about mages, rival nations, and government agents was told with a great combination of mirth and drama. I’ve been sitting here for a while trying to conjure up details about this book, and I really can’t. I had a blast reading this very strange book and the rest of the series, that much I remember.

R The Rabbit Factory

The Rabbit Factory

Marshall Karp’s debut novel is another mix of comedy and drama—a pair of LA Homicide detectives investigate a murder at a place that is totally not Disneyland. There’s pressure from the amusement park as well as the police brass for them to find the killer—especially when other bodies are found in/around the park. The detectives have a fantastic rapport and friendship, the extended families (or maybe just one of them has family we spend time with) are a hoot, and the mystery was great. I read this three or four times pre-2010 and loved it every time.

 

Y Yesterday's Hero

Yesterday’s Hero

This is the second in Jonathan Wood’s series about a British police officer who’s brought into MI37—the service in charge of dealing with supernatural threats to the UK. This is a combo platter of Science Fiction, Urban Fantasy, and Spy novel, told with a sharp sense of humor. Arthur Wallace is the protagonist, and the point of entry character into this strange world—but his team is made up of a fantastic ensemble of characters. This is another series I need to revisit.

 

 

FIRST IMPRESSIONS: The Goodbye Coast by Joe Ide: A Phillip Marlowe for Today

The Goodbye Coast Tour Banner

The Goodbye CoastThe Goodbye Coast

by Joe Ide

DETAILS:
Publisher: Weidenfeld & Nicolson (UK)/Mulholland Books (US)
Publication Date: February 17, 2022 (UK), February 1, 2022 (US)
Format: Hardcover
Length: 301 pg.
Read Date: February 12-?
Support Independent Bookstores - Visit IndieBound.org


Let me start out by saying this isn’t going to be my traditional post about a book—hopefully, that will comes later this week. Due to some miscommunication, misunderstanding, breakdown in communication, or some other human error, I didn’t get the advanced copy of the book for this tour stop. Stuff happens, it’s not the end of the world.

Thankfully, before I’d signed up for the tour, I’d put a hold on this book at my local library, and my turn in the queue came up in time for me to check the book out Saturday. I had enough time to read the first third (I’m on page 103 of 301) of it, so I can talk about a decent amount of the book. Honestly, given my typical approach, I’m going to be able to say almost as much about the book as I would anyway—I just can’t say anything about how successful the ending might be.

Faulty Assumption

When I heard that Joe Ide was going to do a Philip Marlowe novel, I assumed it was going to be in the same vein as his South Central Sherlock Holmes novel, IQ-this time with a Marlowe-esque figure in a contemporary L.A.

Nope. This time out, Ide isn’t messing around with something inspired by one of the greats. He’s it’s a full bore re-imagining. We’ve got Philip Marlowe in his tenth year of being a P.I. in a 2020-is L.A. The question is, will this work?

What’s The Goodbye Coast About?

An aging star of Rom-Coms hires Marlowe to find her stepdaughter, a 16-year-old runaway, Cody. Cody’s father, Terry, was a director who had one mega-success and a series of flops. He appears to have fallen in with a group of Russian and Albanian gangsters as a way to secure funding for one last attempt at saving his career. Sadly, he was murdered in front of their home. That was six weeks ago. A month later, Cody runs away, stealing the housekeeper’s car to do so.

It’s been two weeks, and no sign of her has been found. Kendra James hires Marlowe, not to look into the murder, but to track down Cody. Something doesn’t sit right about this with Marlowe, but James is paying a ridiculous amount of money, so he takes the case. Marlowe definitely doesn’t like James, the way she treats her staff, or spends her money. But that doesn’t mean he can’t some of that money.

Naturally, Marlowe ends up looking into the murder, and the questions surrounding it, the victim, and Marlowe’s client start to add up.

While in the middle of this investigation, Marlowe is approached by a British woman looking for her son—her ex-husband has abducted the boy and flown home to L.A. as the lastest step in their bitter divorce. She’s spent pretty much everything she has to get to L.A., and after a series of rejections from Private Investigators who expect to be paid for their efforts, she’s been referred to Marlowe.

Emmett Marlowe

Marlowe’s father, Emmett, is a 17-year-veteran of the LAPD. Currently on leave, following the death of his wife from cancer and the excessive and habitual drinking he turned to.

The relationship between father and son is strained, and the closest they get is when they work together—Emmett is essentially Marlowe’s partner in some of his cases, unofficially using LAPD resources in the service of the case.

It seems like the emotional core of this novel is going to be the relationship between Emmett and Marlowe. I don’t expect a giant breakthrough in the next two hundred pages, but I hope there’s a little thawing of the ice.

Phillip Marlowe, Really?

I’m really not sure about this part. How Phillip Marlowe-y is this guy? Do we need Marlowe in the 21st Century? I wondered about that as soon as I finally understood what Ide was doing in this book a few weeks ago, and at this point in the book, I still have questions about that.

One thing that I stumbled over is Ide’s use of the third person. Chandler’s Marlowe is notably a first-person narrator—and his narration served as the template for so many P.I.s that followed. Ide is about to work in some touches that make me think of Chandler’s narration but it’s not the same and takes some getting used to.

There are plenty of similarities between the two author’s take on the character, a similar attitude, aptitude, mannerisms, and likes. On the other hand, Ide’s Marlowe’s backstory and the involvement of his father are significant divergences. That’s his prerogative, and there’s nothing inherently wrong with that—but at a certain point, if enough tweaks are made, is it Phillip Marlowe?

I cannot stress enough—I would have absolutely no qualms about this character if he had any other name under the sun. But tagging him with Philip Marlowe means something, right? I’m ready and willing to be convinced that Ide knew what he was doing with this, but I’m not there yet.

What Are My First Impressions of The Goodbye Coast?

I’m telling you now, if I didn’t have prior obligations and responsibilities, I’d have easily stayed up all night reading this. I was hooked and hooked solidly. I’m more than eager to dive back into this today, and the novel I started the day before I picked this up is going to have to wait a little longer, there’s no way I’m not finishing this as soon as I can.

I’ve said literally everything I know about the father taking the child story, so I can’t say much about it. I can say that the best bit of dialogue in the novel comes from the first conversation that Mom and Marlowe had. I’m a sucker for banter, and Ide nailed this one.

The dialogue as a whole is crisp, snappy, and witty. The characters leap off the page, and it didn’t take me long to get invested in the whole thing. This version of L.A. shares a lot with Chandlers, too—the collision of an abundance of wealth and a dearth of ethics/morality helps to create a dynamite setting for a P.I. novel.

Everything about the Cody/Terry/Kendra case is murky—Marlowe’s going to end up digging up some real dark secrets soon, I’m sure. I expect that things are going to get violent and action-packed.

It’s early days yet with this character, but I can see him rivaling Isaiah Quintabe in my eyes. I cannot wait to see what happens in the rest of the book, and I fully expect to be raving about it when I’m done. Go get your hands on this.

This post contains an affiliate link. If you purchase from it, I will get a small commission at no additional cost to you. As always, opinions are my own.

My thanks to Tracy Fenton and Compulsive Readers for the invitation to participate in this tour and the materials they provided.

BOOK SPOTLIGHT: The Goodbye Coast by Joe Ide

I’m excited to welcome the Compulsive Reader Book Tour for Joe Ide’s new novel, The Goodbye Coast this morning. If you haven’t tried a Joe Ide book before, this is a great one to make his acquaintance with. I’ve got this little spotlight post and some first impressions of the novel coming along in a bit. Let’s start by learning a little about this book, okay?

The Goodbye Coast Tour Banner

Book Details:

Book Title: The Goodbye Coast by Joe Ide
Publisher: Weidenfeld & Nicolson (UK)/Mulholland Books (US)
Release date: February 17, 2022 (UK), February 1, 2022 (US)
Format: Hardcover/Ebook/Audiobook
Length: 301 pages
The Goodbye Coast

About the Book:

Raymond Chandler’s iconic detective, Philip Marlowe, gets a dramatic and colourful reinvention at the hands of award-winning novelist Joe Ide.

The seductive and relentless figure of Raymond Chandler’s detective, Philip Marlowe, is vividly re-imagined in present-day Los Angeles. Here is a city of scheming Malibu actresses, ruthless gang members, virulent inequality, and washed-out police. Acclaimed and award-winning novelist Joe Ide imagines a Marlowe very much of our time: he’s a quiet, lonely, and remarkably capable and confident private detective, though he lives beneath the shadow of his father, a once-decorated LAPD homicide detective, famous throughout the city, who’s given in to drink after the death of Marlowe’s mother.

Marlowe, against his better judgment, accepts two missing person cases, the first a daughter of a faded, tyrannical Hollywood starlet, and the second, a British child stolen from his mother by his father. At the center of THE GOODBYE COAST is Marlowe’s troubled and confounding relationship with his father, a son who despises yet respects his dad, and a dad who’s unable to hide his bitter disappointment with his grown boy. Together, they will realize that one of their clients may be responsible for the murder of her own husband, a washed-up director in debt to Albanian and Russian gangsters, and that the client’s trouble-making daughter may not be what she seems.

Steeped in the richly detailed ethnic neighborhoods of modern LA, Ide’s GOODBYE COAST is a bold recreation that is viciously funny, ingeniously plotted, and surprisingly tender.

Sunshine and skullduggery, movie stars and mayhem – Joe Ide brings us a Philip Marlowe who wears our twenty-first century like a well-cut suit” – Ian Rankin

About the Author:

Joe IdeJoe Ide grew up in South Central Los Angeles. His favourite books were the Conan Doyle Sherlock Holmes stories. The idea that a person could face the world and vanquish his enemies with just his intelligence fascinated him. Joe went on to earn a graduate degree and had several careers before writing IQ, his debut novel, inspired by his early experiences and love of Sherlock. Joe lives in Santa Monica, California.

My thanks to Tracy Fenton and Compulsive Readers for the invitation to participate in this tour and the materials they provided.

The Lost Discipline of Conversation by Joanne J. Jung: Seemed to Lose the Thread

The Lost Discipline of ConversationThe Lost Discipline of Conversation:
Surprising Lessons in Spiritual Formation
Drawn from the English Puritans

by Joanne J. Jung

DETAILS:
Publisher: Zondervan
Publication Date:  June 12, 2018
Format: Kindle Edition
Length: 224
Read Date: February 6, 2022
Support Independent Bookstores - Visit IndieBound.org

From the Back of the Book:

Recovering Spiritual Practices of the Past titles reach beyond commonly known spiritual formation practices in order to mine the wisdom of the past, bringing to light ways of thinking, living, and growing in Christ that the church today has largely overlooked.

In The Lost Discipline of Conversation, spiritual formation professor and author Joanne Jung walks readers through the Puritan practice of “conference,” or focused, spiritual conversations intended to promote ongoing transformation. An antidote to privatized faith, conference calls believers to biblical literacy and soul care in a context of transparency and accountability.

Useful for believers in any sphere or ministry or stage in life, conference is ultimately a tool for nurturing mutual, godly authenticity within community.

Beyond the Back of the Book

Part I, “Rediscovering a ‘Lost’ Means of Grace,” outlined the need for community and the benefit of this practice (although equating it with the Means of Grace is questionable).

Part II looks at the various contexts in which conferencing can take place and suggests some ways to promote it. I lost track of the idea of conferencing during this Part—it seemed so flexible so as to maybe lose meaning.

Part III

Part III is called “Soul-to-Soul Bible Studies,” and added nothing to the work. They were scripts/prompts to guide you through a one-on-one (or larger) study of a handful of seemingly random New Testament passages. The explanatory notes were redundant, and not incredibly useful.

I didn’t see the point of this part at all.

So, what did I think about The Lost Discipline of Conversation?

Seven years before this was published, Jung published Godly Conversation: Rediscovering the Puritan Practice of Conference, and I can’t help but wonder what my reaction to this book would be if I’d read it first. This feels like it’s building on the work done in the initial book. Maybe I’d walk away from this with a greater understanding of both Jung’s overall project as well as the Puritan practice of conference. Still, this book needs to be able to stand on its own, and it just doesn’t.

The biggest question I have from this book is what’s the foundation for this practice? How is “conferencing” based on, or built on, Puritan thought? You can’t follow Puritan practices (on this or any other point) without their teaching backing it up—it just doesn’t work that way. Leave that to Finney and those who follow in his footsteps, not to Bownd, Owen, or Alleine. Practices without the theology are meaningless actions. It’s not “do X, Y, and Z” to get spiritual growth in a mechanistic/automatic way, it’s not powdered milk where you just add water. The Puritans acted in certain ways (like conferences) because of something. Jung did her readers a disservice leaving that out.

I don’t necessarily contest the value of the practice, but I don’t know that she’s convinced me that it’s as valuable as she sets it out to be. I’ve read a good number of the original sources she cites, and I never got the inkling that this was particularly vital—useful, potentially, but as important as this?

I do have to wonder why the title specifies “English Puritans” when there’s so many citations of New England Puritanism. The distinctions aren’t huge, but there are differences. Just delete the word “English,” and it’s better. That seems picky, and probably is. But at a certain point, the quibbles I had with the material overwhelmed the pros, and the little ones got under my skin more than they should.

I feel bad about thinking like this about the book, because the person that recommended this to me clearly thought I’d appreciate it—and I wanted to. But this is largely a swing and a miss for me. At the risk of repeating myself, I do wonder what my reaction to this would’ve been had I read Godly Conversation first. As it is, though, I’ll chalk this up as a well-intentioned miss.


2 1/2 Stars

This post contains an affiliate link. If you purchase from it, I will get a small commission at no additional cost to you. As always, opinions are my own.

Saturday Miscellany—2/12/22

Today’s post feels a bit further over on the miscellany spectrum than others. And I can never decide if that’s a good or a bad thing. I think I prefer the more scattershot lists. Prefer it or not, it’s what I have today. ¯_(ツ)_/¯

Odds ‘n ends about books and reading that caught my eye this week. You’ve probably seen some/most/all of them, but just in case:
bullet Has Literature Ever Changed the Course of History?
bullet I assume many of you, like me, have been seeing plenty of chatter about book lengths recently. I thought John Scalzi’s reply on a reddit thread pretty useful
bullet 8 Unique Libraries in the United States—poor use of “unique” and lack of links/pictures aside, this is an interesting look at some notable U.S. libraries
bullet Humor in Books, and Other Places, Too! An Interview with Peat Long
bullet The Gaiman Guide—a handy-dandy guide to Gaiman for those looking for a way into his oeuvre
bullet How Non-Librarians Imagine a Librarian’s Typical Workday—This isn’t really how it is?
bullet How Lee Child’s Killing Floor Was Transformed Into “Reacher”—Child’s biographer takes a look at the first season
bullet Tips for Writing a Good Book Review—Some handy tips/reminders from NetGalley’s blog
bullet What Should I Write About?—A question most bloggers have asked themselves.
bullet Why Should You Reread Books?—a few thoughts from Ramona Mead.
bullet What really happens after rom coms…—Just in time for Valentine’s Day

Things I learned from reading this week (that I can’t imagine finding a use for):
bullet The first recorded use of “easy peasy lemon squeezy” was from 1983. How is that possible? Doesn’t that seem generations late? (from Jumping Sharks and Dropping Mics by Gareth Carrol)

Lastly, I’d like to say hi and extend a warm welcome to Alphabet Ravine, who followed the blog this week. Don’t be a stranger.

The Friday 56 for 2/11/22: Life, The Universe, and Everything by Douglas Adams

The Friday 56This is a weekly bloghop hosted by Freda’s Voice.

RULES:
The Friday 56 Grab a book, any book.
The Friday 56 Turn to Page 56 or 56% on your ereader. If you have to improvise, that is okay.
The Friday 56 Find a snippet, short and sweet.
The Friday 56 Post it.

Another week where there’s nothing I can share from my current read. However, the book I’m reading is discussing the third book in the Hitchhiker’s Guide trilogy. That’s close enough for me…

from Page 56 of:
Life, The Universe, and Everything

Life, The Universe, and Everything by Douglas Adams

“Ask me if I ever get bored, go on, ask me.”

The mattress did.

Marvin ignored the question, he merely trudged with added emphasis.

“I gave a speech once,” he said suddenly and apparently unconnectedly. “You may not instantly see why I bring the subject up, but that is because my mind works so phenomenally fast, and I am at a rough estimate thirty billion times more intelligent than you. Let me give you an example. Think of a number, any number.”

“Er, five,” said the mattress.

“Wrong,” said Marvin. “You see?”

The mattress was much impressed by this and realized that he was in the presence of a not unremarkable mind.

Page 257 of 623

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén